America’s Authoritarian Turn and What We Must Do
A European invitation to clarity, courage, and coordinated action
The warnings are no longer abstract. The boundary that separates a noisy, imperfect democracy from an authoritarian system is being rubbed out in front of our eyes. When a government treats dissent as a security threat, sanitizes the nation's historical record, and punishes journalism for doing its job, it is not engaged in heated partisanship. It is dismantling the public space that citizens need in order to remain free.
Authoritarian systems often begin with a feeling, not a law. There is a shift in the atmosphere. Loyalty is valued more than competence. Agencies learn to protect a person, not a principle. Courts are used as theaters of intimidation rather than arenas for honest adjudication. The culture is recoded so that criticism equals betrayal and silence is the safest choice. Each move can be explained away as a misunderstanding or a necessary correction. Taken together, they assemble into a machine.
The United States has moved far along this track. The language of terror is pointed inward. Public memory is polished until it resembles patriotic wallpaper rather than history. Newsrooms are punished through process rather than proof. Law enforcement is pressured to bend toward personal will. This is not a collection of accidents. It is a project. What follows maps the pattern and proposes a path of resistance while time still matters.
From label to weapon: how "terror" gets aimed inward
Start with clarity. Antifa is not an organization. There is no leadership, membership roll, treasury, or legal entity to designate. It is a loose current of anti-fascist practice. To brand this current a terrorist organization is not to describe reality. It is to manufacture a lever. Once power decides that a non-organization equals terrorism, anyone who resists fascism can be smeared as part of an invented threat.
Even without a domestic terrorist list in statute, the single word terrorist bends the legal environment. That word can justify aggressive surveillance, blanket arrests at demonstrations, terrorism-style enhancements at sentencing, and an investigative posture that treats protest as pre-crime. The point is not legal elegance. The point is permission. Officers, prosecutors, judges, and juries each hear the signal and act a little differently. The cumulative effect is chilling.
The danger is systemic. If the state recodes opposition as terror, tragedy will be framed to fit the script and everyday confrontations will be overcharged. A scuffle becomes a conspiracy. A broken window becomes a narrative of subversion. Prosecutors are nudged to seek the harshest tools, judges are encouraged to set examples, and citizens learn a lesson that authoritarians rely on. Speaking up is costly. Staying home is safer.
This is also how the label spreads. Once a government normalizes the word terrorist for domestic critics, state legislators copy the rhetoric and write their own versions into law. Donors and NGOs that support civil rights are drawn into theatrical investigations. Universities tighten rules on gatherings to avoid trouble. Social platforms flag lawful activism as potential extremism. The infrastructure of democracy begins to treat dissent like a disease to be contained.
Editing the past: state power and the battle for memory
Authoritarians do not merely jail opponents. They curate the past. A democracy invites citizens to face their whole story. Pride and shame together. An authoritarian project sands the rough edges until only a pleasing tale survives. Directives to review exhibits about slavery, dispossession, indigenous erasure, and state abuse send a clear message to curators and teachers. Use soft language. Avoid words that make the powerful uncomfortable. Trim the rest.
This is not heritage. It is sanitization. Honest memory strengthens a republic because it trains adults to handle complexity. Citizens who can hold two truths at once are harder to manipulate. Citizens raised on a diet of patriotic screensavers are far easier to command. When museums remove difficult placards, when gift shops drop difficult books, when classrooms replace difficult chapters with silence, the result is not unity. It is amnesia on demand.
Control over the archive becomes control over the present. If a society is taught that brutal realities were exaggerated or impolite to mention, then current abuses can be painted as overreactions by hysterical critics. The lesson migrates quickly. From museums to newsrooms. From classrooms to courts. A public trained to look away from yesterday's cruelty will look away again when that cruelty is repackaged for today.
Europe has seen this method. In every illiberal turn, the purge of memory precedes the purge of rights. The order is intentional. Conscience is blunted first. Resistance becomes harder later. That is why the fight for accurate public history is not an academic debate about plaques and phrasing. It is a defense of civic immunity.
Silencing by cost: the new censorship of the press
The cleanest way to control a free press without formal bans is to make truth too expensive. File suits with eye-watering numbers and inventive theories of harm. Drag editors through discovery for years. Harass individual reporters and punish sources. You do not need to win on the merits if the process itself becomes the penalty. The next controversial story dies on the editor's desk, sacrificed to budget and sleep.
Soft censorship completes the job. Leaders single out journalists by name, freeze access for disfavored outlets, and reward flattering coverage with exclusives. Corporations that rely on federal approvals or procurement read the signs and steer their advertising accordingly. Local newsrooms, already thin, shrink further. In the gaps, a river of partisan channels flows, rewarding loyalty over verification and access over evidence.
Then comes the harassment ratchet. Coordinated abuse campaigns target reporters, especially women and people of color. Doxxing, threats, and swarms of bad-faith complaints raise the cost of investigative work. Public broadcasters are smeared as partisan and threatened with cuts. Antitrust is waved like a club at platforms that host critical content while friendly consolidations pass with a nod. None of this needs a censor's office. A climate of punishment is enough.
The result is a market where truth cannot compete with access, and where fear outbids verification. When citizens are trained to treat journalism as a team sport rather than a civic function, accountability becomes optional. Democracies do not last long under those conditions. Without a resilient press, corruption multiplies, cruelty hides, and the public square collapses into spectacle.
Bending the badge: inside the capture of law and police
A leader who seeks impunity does not have to abolish the law. He can capture the people who apply it. Personnel is the first battlefield. Professionals who ask hard questions are sidelined. Loyalists with thin résumés are elevated. The message travels quickly through the ranks. Advancement depends on serving the leader, not the law.
Structure is the second battlefield. Parallel chains of command appear. Sensitive cases are routed through political gatekeepers. Legal counsel offices act like ideological filter rooms. Investigations begin with targets and work backward to offenses. Enemies are hunted for process crimes. Friends are protected by selective interpretation, strategic delay, and selective amnesia. What was once culture becomes policy.
Charging becomes theater. Enhancements designed for terror plots get strapped to protest files. Venue shopping becomes routine. Discovery is weaponized to drown defendants and exhaust supporters. At the same time, loyal wrongdoers receive public assurances that they will be shielded. Inspectors general are moved. Whistleblowers are discredited with precision leaks. The double standard becomes the only standard.
Surveillance tools drift inward. Watchlists expand. Fusion centers hoover up social media. Administrative subpoenas become muscle memory. Parallel construction hides sensitive sources and methods from courts and defendants. Even if a judge suppresses a case two years later, the chill landed on day one. Trust drains out of the system. Citizens learn that the law belongs to a faction, not to the public.
This is how a republic loses its spine. Not through a single midnight raid, but through a thousand edits to how power meets the law. The antidote is structural and personal. Strong civil service protections for investigators. Real independence for inspectors general. Transparent case-assignment rules. Bright lines on surveillance with penalties that bite. A political culture that treats attacks on judges and career agents as a red line, not as a talk-show hobby.
A pattern you can count, not just feel
Scholars of democratic breakdown have mapped the warning lights for decades. The United States now checks too many at once, and the speed of change is the most alarming metric.
• Rules are treated as flexible. Elections and court limits are accepted when convenient and disparaged when not.
• Opponents are framed as enemies of the nation rather than rivals in a shared civic project.
• Violence is minimized when it comes from the leader's side, and encouraged with winks and nods.
• Civil liberties narrow. Protest is recoded as disorder or terror. Academic freedom and public broadcasting are chilled.
• Referees are captured. Prosecutors, regulators, election officials, and watchdogs are replaced on loyalty screens.
• The information space is flooded until exhaustion outcompetes engagement.
• Emergency language becomes a governing method rather than a temporary tool.
• Intelligence and policing are steered toward critics rather than threats.
• Corruption is normalized as success while oversight is dismantled.
• A cult of personality eclipses institutions.
• Electoral rules are edited for advantage. Losing becomes logically impossible, therefore every loss is illegitimate.
• Foreign strongmen are praised as examples of strength. Liberal democracies are treated as obstacles.
• Minorities are scapegoated to concentrate anger and justify selective enforcement.
When many boxes light up at once, while referees are being replaced, the situation is not drift. It is slide. That is the moment for organized, disciplined, lawful pressure.
Beyond Washington: the transatlantic stakes
What happens in Washington travels. When the most powerful democracy recodes dissent as terror, rewrites public history, and punishes the press, that template is exported by authoritarians and copied by fence sitters. Alliances that rely on shared norms begin to wobble. Ukraine's lifeline thins. Sanctions coalitions crack. Authoritarian capital looks for weak points in universities, media markets, ports, and political parties.
Europe, the United Kingdom, Canada, and democratic partners in the Indo-Pacific should answer with policy rather than pageantry. First, downgrade ceremonial hospitality that launders illiberal conduct. Friendship can be frank. Second, reduce exposure to tariff shocks and political blackmail. Build a resilience package that covers critical minerals, semiconductors, medicines, and energy inputs. Third, weaponize transparency for democracy. Fund cross-border investigative journalism. Create legal defense pools so process cannot silence editors. Establish an early-warning mechanism that tracks attacks on courts, press, academia, and protest space in real time.
Security cooperation must be conditioned on rule of law. Narrow intelligence sharing when domestic surveillance is turned on journalists and activists. Tighten export controls when agencies become tools of political repression. Offer refuge and fellowships to scholars, reporters, and civil servants who need time and safety to keep working. Friendship without conditions is not solidarity. It is accommodation.
Cities and civil society have roles too. Sister-city networks can host democracy forums and provide platforms for threatened American voices. Universities can add democratic conditionality to exchanges. Major sports and cultural institutions can refuse to be used as propaganda backdrops. Consumers can demand supply-chain standards from brands that profit from censorship or disinformation. Democratic habits scale when ordinary actors use their leverage.
Do the work: how people shift institutions
Institutions matter, but people move them. The most effective counter to authoritarian slide is collective, disciplined, lawful pressure from below. Presence, persistence, and precision.
Show up. Peaceful mass presence alters political risk. Do not wait for a single march. Fill council chambers and court steps. Pair rallies with teach-ins so new supporters leave with skills. Build coalitions that cross class and culture. Students, unions, veterans, faith communities, immigrant associations, business owners, artists. Democracy is strongest when different tribes stand together.
Flood the inboxes. Call and write every level of government. Ask for hard commitments in public. No domestic terrorism powers that criminalize protest. No funding for political purges. Protection for inspectors general, civil service, and public media. Insist on votes, not vibes. Publish who responded and who hid. Reward courage. Punish silence at the ballot box.
Defend the information space. Prebunk common falsehoods before they land. Debunk with receipts when they do. Share clear explainers. Report coordinated abuse. When creators are targeted, organize advertiser pressure on disinformation channels. Subscribe to local and investigative outlets so facts have resources. Without public support, truth is outspent.
Build rapid response. Keep contact trees for lawyers, medics, legal observers, translators, and trained de-escalators. Document abuses with time, place, and clear video. Back up securely. File public-records requests. Light is a habit, not a headline.
Protect those most at risk now, not later. Court accompaniment, bail funds, safe rides, hotlines, translation. When minorities are defended early, permission for broader repression weakens. Courage spreads when no one stands alone.
Turn professions into platforms. Lawyers staff clinics and file impact cases. Teachers audit curricular purges and defend honest history. Technologists secure communications and map propaganda networks. Health workers track the human cost of repression. Creators make the narrative vivid for people who will never read a legal brief. Every skill has a democratic use.
Make elections competent. Volunteer as a poll worker or nonpartisan observer. Help neighbors register and secure valid ID. Track rule changes. Support litigation that keeps polling places open and ballots counted. Authoritarian projects rely on confusion. Competence is resistance.
Use targeted economic pressure. Spend with companies that protect civil space. Ask councils and pension funds to exclude vendors that attack the press or profit from censorship and surveillance. Money always has a voice. Make it speak for democracy.
Coordinate across borders. Diaspora communities and allies can lobby parliaments, condition diplomatic hospitality, and resource cross-border journalism. Friendship and pressure can live in the same sentence.
Call to clarity
This may be one of the last opportunities to pull back from an outcome that once felt impossible. The United States, a flawed but vital democratic beacon, is at risk of becoming the world's largest authoritarian power. Not in theory. In practice. The signs are visible. If we narrate this as ordinary politics, we will explain our way into defeat.
Use the power you already hold. Stand in public. Call and write until officials feel the cost of silence. Counter lies in your circles. Fund reporting. Defend those targeted. Volunteer for elections. Spend with intent. Ask allies to apply pressure that respects friendship by defending principle.
Name the project. It is not reform. It is capture. Treat it accordingly. Draw bright lines. Demand backbone. Refuse the spectacle that says nothing can be done. Everything that matters in a democracy is built by people who acted before it felt safe.
The Atlantic story was always about mutual reinforcement. Europe and America correcting each other, holding to shared norms, and making free space for memory, law, and truth. If we still believe in that story, prove it. With law. With pressure. With solidarity. And with the stubborn refusal to be silent.
📨 Stay Informed. Stand Up.
All our work is published freely on Juste Flamme's Substack, because the defense of democracy should never be paywalled.
But if you believe in what we do, confronting authoritarianism, exposing disinformation, and standing up for a free, inclusive society, consider becoming a paid subscriber.
Your support helps us go further, dig deeper, and reach more people in the fight for truth and liberty.